Peer review for 2 people using the following point values:


1)  Have included a logical advantage for a population to have the adaptation chosen (5 pts)

2)  Have included mention that "variation exists" in this population in terms of this trait (3 pts).

3)  Have included that this population "overproduces" offspring (3 pts).

4)  Have included that this population "struggles for resources and existence" (3 pts).

5)  Have included that "individuals most suited to the environment" / having this trait are the ones that have an advantage and survive (3 pts).

6)  Have included that survivors having this trait "reproduce" offspring having this trait (3 pts).

7)  Mechanics (spelling and use of language) (2 pts)

8)  Organization (reads smoothly and is easy to follow) (2 pts)

9)  Classified the selection correctly as directional, stabilizing, or disruptive. (5 pts)


To do your peer review just "reply" to posting of the person you are reviewing.  You can copy the following into your reply:

1)  logical advantage (5 possible):
2)  variation exists (3 possible):
3)  overproduce (3 possible):
4)  struggles for existence (3 possible):
5)  natural selection (3 possible):
6)  survivors reproduce (3 possible):
7)  mechanics (2 pts)
8)  organization (2 pts)
9)  correct classification (5 pts)

TOTAL POINTS OUT OF 29 =

COMMENTS FROM EVALUTATOR: